Sellf Media Logo
Strategy · Creative · Media · Technology · Real Growth.
Blog

Budgets Start With Repeatable Growth

Published on November 16, 2026
Budgets Start With Repeatable Growth

Home Depot will announce its third-quarter results on November 17, followed by Target on November 18 and Walmart on November 19. When the reports come out, we’ll probably look first at growth in revenue, operating profit, or earnings per share. As we read those numbers, we ask how much of the increase we can build into next quarter’s budget. Home Depot · Target · Walmart

It’s easy to assume that a strong quarter sets a new baseline for the business. The same increase in operating profit could come from fewer product returns or from clearing old inventory. If the change that reduced returns stays in place, we have a basis for budgeting that benefit. To earn the same contribution from a clearance, we’d need another batch of inventory to sell off. In their study of earnings persistence, Dechow and Ge found that special items were the main reason earnings were less persistent in one group of companies they studied. Dechow and Ge, 2006

The One-Off Item Filter starts by identifying the items that moved the growth rate and quantifying their impact. We then ask three questions about each item to see how much of the reported result can go into the budget and which effects could reverse next quarter.

1. Would this item recur next quarter under the same conditions?

In the quarterly results it published in August, Walmart reported revenue growth of 5.9%, or 5.1% at constant currency. The 0.8 percentage-point gap shows how much currency translation affected reported growth. The 5.1% figure gives us a starting point once we’ve isolated the currency effect. The other two questions help us understand where the remaining growth came from. Walmart, second-quarter financial results

At this stage, we set aside tax or tariff refunds, gains from asset sales, period-specific currency effects, and unusual inventory clearances. We apply the same test to expenses. Required maintenance is a cost of doing business even if it falls in a different month each year. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s guidance also treats operating expenses that arise at irregular intervals as recurring when they occur repeatedly or occasionally. SEC, non-GAAP financial measures guidance

2. Did this item come from a business decision or an external event?

A retailer might see its return rate fall after adding more accurate sizing information to product pages. If the improvement holds across similar products and customer groups, the retailer can roll out the change more widely and reproduce the margin benefit. Orders that came in because a competitor ran out of stock for two weeks depend on that situation recurring. If the retailer can track repeat purchases from the customers it gained, it can assess that contribution separately.

To budget for the effect of a decision, we need to be able to execute it again with the same unit economics. Repeating the discount that drove sales may be easy. What matters is whether the profit contribution holds after factoring in discounts, returns, logistics, and additional customer acquisition costs.

3. Could this item reverse?

A promotion that pulls October orders into September makes the third quarter look stronger. Some of that boost reverses in the fourth quarter when those customers skip their October orders. The business can run the promotion again and shift demand between quarters again. To see how much additional demand it generated, we look at what the same customers bought during the promotion and over the following weeks. Deferred routine maintenance works in much the same way. The cost lands in a later period when the work gets done.

When we read this week’s reports, we can look at total revenue alongside comparable sales at Home Depot, sales growth alongside operating margin at Target, and reported revenue alongside constant-currency revenue at Walmart. The footnotes and management commentary help us identify the items behind those movements, how large they were, and how they could affect the next period. If the disclosure gives no figure for an item, we need to quantify its contribution before building it into the budget.

From core growth to the budget

Suppose a retailer’s operating profit rose from TRY 10 million in the same quarter last year to TRY 12.5 million this quarter. Reported growth is 25%. To recalculate it, we subtract temporary gains and add back one-off expenses in both periods.

Operating profit and adjustments (TRY million)

Same quarter last year

This quarter

Reported operating profit

10.0

12.5

One-off compensation from a supplier

−0.5

0

Net profit contribution from inventory clearance

0

−1.2

Net profit contribution from orders pulled forward

0

−0.8

One-off contract expense from closing a warehouse

0

+0.3

Core operating profit

9.5

10.8

After these adjustments, core growth is approximately 13.7%. The same calculation works for revenue using sales figures, and for earnings per share (EPS) using after-tax effects and the weighted-average share count.

At Sellf, we use this distinction in our Real Growth Index (RGI) reviews as the starting point for budgets, targets, and bonuses. The board report shows the actual result alongside the items that affected it. In the budget, we start with repeatable profit and account separately for the shortfall that pulled-forward demand will create next quarter. The case for new spending rests on the additional profit and return on investment it can generate from that baseline.

We took the same approach in our Williams-Sonoma analysis, reading the one-off effect separately from the company’s operating performance. Sellf’s Williams-Sonoma analysis

If you stripped out the one-off effects from the two periods in your latest quarterly comparison, which budget decision would change?

Related Insights